I found this comparative chart of Q reconstructions in Kloppenborg's essay on Chapter 11 of Kloppenborg's Synoptic Problems: Collected Essays:
Q (numbered as found in Luke) |
Schultz |
Polag |
Jacobson |
Schmithals |
Schenk |
Kloppenborg |
Sato |
Zeller |
Mack |
Mack's Q |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1972 | 1977 | 1978/1992 | 1979,80,85 | 1981 | 1987/1990 | 1988 | 1977,82,84 | 1994 | ||
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | (9) | ||
(3:2-4) | -- | SpR? | Q2 | -- | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | 03:01-06 | |
3:7-9 | Q2 | SpR | Qcr | Q1 | Q | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | 03:07-09 |
3:16bd | Q2 | SpR | Qc | Q2 | Qr | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | 03:16-17 |
3:16c | Q2 | SpR | Qi | Q2 | Q | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | |
3:17 | Q2 | SpR | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | |
[3:21-32] | -- | SpR | Qc | Q2 | -- | -- | A | Q? | ||
4:1-13 | Q2 | SpR | Q3 | Q2 | Qr | Q3 | SpE | Q3 | Q3 | 04:01-13 |
[4:16] | -- | ? | -- | -- | -- | ? | A | -- | ||
<6:20a> | -- | H | ? | ? | Q | Q1 | A | Q | Q1 | 06:20a |
6:20b-21 | Q1 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | 06:20-23 |
6:22-23b | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Qr | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | |
6:23c | Q2 | H | Qcr | Q1 | Qr | Q2r | A | Q1 | Q1 | |
(6:24-26) | -- | ? | -- | Q1? | -- | Q2 | QLk | QLk | ||
6:27-28,32-33, 35c | Q1 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | 06:27-35 |
(6:34-35b) | -- | -- | Qc? | -- | -- | Q1 | A? | -- | Q1 | |
6:29-30 | Q1 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | |
(Q/Matt 5:41) | -- | H | -- | -- | -- | Q1 | A | -- | ||
6:31 | Q1 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | |
6:36 | Q1 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | 06:36-38 |
6:37b, 38c | Q1 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | |
(6:37c-38b) | -- | Ha | Qc? | -- | -- | Q1 | QLk | -- | Q1 | |
6:39b | Q2 | H | Qcr | Q? | Q | Q1 | SpE | ? | Q1 | 06:39-40 |
6:40 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q? | Q | Q1 | SpE | ? | Q1 | |
6:41-42 | Q1 | H | Qc | Q? | Q | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | 06:41-42 |
6:43-45 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | SpE | Q1 | Q1 | 06:43-45 |
6:46 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q2? | Qr | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | 06:46-49 |
6:47-49 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1? | Q* | Q1 | A | Q1 | Q1 | |
7:1a | Q2 | SpR | Qcr | Q2 | Q | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | 07:01-10 |
7:1b-2, 6-10 | Q2 | SpR | Qcr | Q2 | Q | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | |
7:18-19, (20) | Q2 | Ha | Qi | Q2 | Qr | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | 07:18-23 |
7:22 | Q2 | Ha | Qi | Q2 | Q | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | |
7:23 | Q2 | Ha | Qi | Q2 | Qr | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | |
7:24-26a | Q2 | Ha | Qc | Q2 | Q* | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | 07:24-28 |
7:26b | Q2 | Ha | Qc | Q2 | Qr | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | |
7:27 | Q2 | SpR | Qc | Q2 | Qr | Q2 | SpE | Q | Q2a | |
7:28a | Q2 | SpR | Qi | Q1 | Q | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | |
7:28b | Q2 | SpR | Qi | Q1 | Qr | Q2 | A | Q | Q2a | |
[7:29-30] | -- | -- | -- | Q2 | Qr | -- | QLk | ? | ||
7:31-32 | Q2 | H | Qcr | Q1 | Q* | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | 07:31-35 |
7:33-35 | Q2 | H | Qcr | Q1* | Qr | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | |
9:57-58 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q2 | Q* | Q1 | B | Q | Q1 | 09:57-62 |
9:59-60 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q2 | Q | Q1 | B | Q | Q1 | |
(9:61-62) | -- | H | -- | -- | -- | Q1 | QLk | -- | Q1 | |
10:02 | Q2 | H | Qi | Q1 | Q | Q1 | B1 | Q1 | Q1 | 10:01-11 |
10:03 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | B | Q1 | Q1 | |
[Q/Matt 10:05-06] | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | (B) | -- | ||
[Q/Matt 10:23] | -- | H | -- | Q1 | -- | -- | (B) | -- | ||
10:4-11 | Q2 | Ha | Qc* | Q1 | Q | Q1 | B | Q1 | Q1 | |
10:12 | Q2 | H | Qcr | Q2r | Q2r | Q2r | C | Q1 | Q2a | 10:12 |
10:13-15 | Q2 | H | Qc* | Q2 | Q2r | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | 10:13-15 |
10:16 | Q2 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q1 | Q1 | Br | Q1 | Q2b | 10:16 |
10:21 | Q2 | SpR | Qi | Q1 | Q2r | Q2 | B | Q | Q3 | 10:21-22 |
10:22 | Q2 | SpR | Qi | Q2 | Q2r | Q2 | SpE | Q3? | Q3 | |
10:23b-24 | Q2 | SpR | ? | Q2 | Q2r | Q2 | B | Q | Q2b | 10:23-24 |
[10:25-28] | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | SpE | Q? | ||
[11:1b] | -- | H | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | Q | Q1 | 11:01-04 |
11:2-4 | Q1 | H | Qi | Q1 | Q | Q1 | SpE | Q1 | Q1 | |
11:9-10 | Q1 | H | Qi | Q? | Q | Q1 | SpE | Q1 | Q1 | 11:09-13 |
11:11-13 | Q1 | H | Qi | Q? | Q* | Q | SpE | Q1 | Q1 | |
11:14-18a | Q2 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | 11:14-23 |
11:19 | Q2 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q* | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | |
11:20 | Q2 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | |
(11:21-22) | -- | Ha | -- | Q? | -- | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | |
11:23 | Q2 | Ha | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q2 | C | Q | Q2b | 11:23 |
11:24-26 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q? | Q | Q2 | C | QS | Q2b | 11:24-26 |
(11:27-28) | -- | -- | Qc | -- | -- | Q2 | -- | -- | Q3 | 11:27-28 |
11:16, 29 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q* | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | 11:16,29-32 |
11:30 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Qr | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | |
11:31-32 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q* | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | |
11:33 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q2 | SpE | Q | Q2b | 11:33-35 |
11:34-35 (36) | Q2 | H | Qc | Q? | Q1 | Q2 | SpE | Q | Q2b | |
11:39b-44, 46-48 | Q1 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | 11:39-52 |
11:42d | Q1 | H | Qc | Q1 | Qr | Q3 | C | Q | Q2a | |
11:49-51a | Q2 | Hr | Qc | Q1 | Q* | Q2 | C* | Q | Q2a | |
11:51b | Q2 | Hr | Qcr? | Q1 | Qr | Q2r | C | Q | Q2a | |
11:52 | Q1 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | |
12:2-3 | Q2 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Q | Q1 | SpE | Q1 | Q1 | 12:02-03 |
12:4-7 | Q1 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Qr | Q1 | SpE | Q1 | Q1 | 12:04-07 |
12:8-9 | Q1 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Qr | Q2 | SpE | Q1 | Q2b | 12:08-12 |
12:10 | Q2 | SpR | Qi? | Q1 | Qr | Q2 | SpE | Q1 | Q2b | |
12:11-12 | Q2 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Qr | Q1 | SpE | Q | Q2b | |
(12:13-14) | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | Q1 | -- | -- | Q1 | 12:13-21 |
(12:16-21) | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- | Q1 | QLk | -- | Q1 | |
12:22b-24, 26-28 | Q1 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Q* | Q1 | SpE? | Q1 | Q1 | 12:22-31 |
12:25 | Q1 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Qr | Q1 | SpE? | Q1 | Q1 | |
12:29-31 | Q1 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Qr | Q1 | SpE | Q1 | Q1 | |
12:33-34 | Q1 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | SpE | Q1 | Q1 | 12:33-34 |
[12:35-38] | -- | H | Qc | Q1 | -- | -- | QLk | Q1? | ||
12:39 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q* | Q2 | SpE | Q1 | Q2a | 12:39-40 |
12:40 | Q2 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Qr | Q2 | SpE | Q1 | Q2a | |
12:42b-46 | Q2 | H | Qi? | Q1 | Q* | Q2 | SpE | Q1 | Q2a | 12:42-46 |
[12:47-48] | -- | SpR | -- | -- | -- | QLk | -- | |||
(12:49) | Q2 | SpR | Qc | -- | -- | Q2 | SpE | -- | Q2a | 12:49-53 |
[12:50] | -- | SpR | -- | -- | SpE | -- | Q2a | |||
12:51-53 | Q2 | SpR | Qc | Q? | Q | Q2 | SpE | Q | Q2a | |
12:54-56 | -- | H | Qc | Q? | -- | Q2 | QLk | ? | Q2a | 12:54-56 |
12:57-59 | Q2 | H | Q? | Q* | Q2 | SpE | ? | Q2a | 12:57-59 | |
13:18-19 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Qr | Q1 | SpE | Q | Q1 | 13:18-21 |
13:20-21 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Qr | Q1 | SpE | Q | Q1 | |
13:23 | -- | Q | Q | -- | C | Q | ||||
13:24 | Q2 | H | Q | Q | Q1 | C | Q | Q2a | 13:24-27 | |
13:(25), 26-27 | Q2 | H | Q | Q | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | ||
13:28-29 | Q2 | H | Q | Q | Q2 | C | Q | Q2a | 13:28-30 | |
13:30 | -- | H | Q | Q | Q2 | -- | -- | Q2a | ||
13:34-35a | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1? | Qr | Q2 | C | Q | Q3 | 13:34-35 |
13:35b | Q2 | H | Qc | Q2r | Qr | Q2r | C | Q | Q3 | |
[14:5] | -- | H | -- | Q | -- | -- | ? | |||
14:11/18:14 | Q2 | ? | Q1 | Q | Q1 | -- | ? | Q1 | 14:11/18:14 | |
14:16-24 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q2 | Q* | Q2 | ? | Q | Q1 | 14:16-24 |
14:26 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | ? | Q | Q1 | 14:26-27;17:33 |
14:27 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q | Q1 | ? | Q | Q1 | |
17:33 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1? | Q | Q1 | ? | Q | Q1 | |
14:34-35 | Q2 | H | Qc | Q1 | Q* | Q1 | ? | Q | Q1 | 14:34-35 |
15:4-7 | Q2 | H | ? | Q1? | Q* | Q1 | ? | Q | Q2b | 15:04-10 |
(15:8-10) | -- | H | ? | -- | -- | Q1 | -- | -- | Q2b | |
16:13 | Q2 | H | Qa | Q1 | Q | Q1 | ? | Q | Q2b | 16:13 |
16:16 | Q2 | H | ? | Q1 | Qr | Q2? | ? | Q | Q3 | 16:16-18 |
16:17 | Q1 | H | ? | Q1 | Q | Q3 | ? | Q | Q3 | |
16:18 | Q1 | H | ? | Q1 | Q | Q1 | ? | Q | Q3 | |
17:1b | -- | H | ? | Q1 | Q | Q1 | ? | Q | Q2b | 17:01-02 |
17:02 | -- | H | ? | Q1 | -- | Q1 | -- | -- | Q2b | |
17:3b-4 | Q2 | H | ? | Q1 | Q | Q1 | ? | Q | Q2b | 17:03-04 |
17:6b | Q2 | H | Q1 | Q1 | Q | Q1 | ? | Q | Q2b | 17:06 |
17:23-24 | Q2 | H | Q1 | Q | Q2 | C | Q1 | Q2a | 17:23-37 | |
17:37b | Q2 | H | Q1 | Qr | Q2 | C | Q1 | Q2a | ||
17:26-27, 30 | Q2 | H | Q1 | Q | Q2 | C | Q1 | Q2a | ||
(17:28-29) | -- | H | Q1? | Q | Q2 | QLk | Q? | Q2a | ||
17:34-35 | Q2 | H | Q1 | Q | Q2 | C | Q1 | Q2a | ||
19:12-13,15b-26 | Q2 | SpR | ? | Q2 | Q* | Q2 | ? | Q | Q2a | 19:11-27 |
22:28-30 | Q2 | H | ? | Q1* | Q* | Q2 | ? | Q | Q3 | 22:28-30 |
Key:
DCHSigla.
-- not in Q
? in Q but attribution uncertain
sub collections
1. Schulz (1972)
Q1 The kerygma of the oldest Palestinian-Syrian Q community
Q2 The kerygma of the younger Syrian Q- community
2. 'Polag (1977)
H Main Collection (Hauptsammlung)
Ha Older clusters (Die älteren Spruchgruppen) predating the Main Collection
Hr Redactional insertions into the Hauptsammlung
SpR Late editing (Spätredaktion)
3. Jacobson (1978, 1992)
Qc compositional stage
Qc* saying with redactional touches
Qcr redaction at the compositional stage
Qi intermediate redaction
Q3 final redaction
4. Schmithals (1979, 1980, 1985)
Q1 nonkerygmatic, pre-Christian stratum
Q1* pre-Christian stratum with slight Q2 influence
Q2 Christological (post-Markan) redaction of Q.
Q2r creation of the redactor of Q.
5. Schenk (1981)
Q included in Q
Qr from the final redactional stratum
Q* traditional but with slight redactional touches
6. Kloppenborg (1987, 1990)
Q1 formative (instructional) stratum
Q2 secondary, polemical stratum
Q2r creation of the secondary redaction
Q3 tertiary glosses
7. Sato (1988)
A Redaction A [(A) = uncertain]
B Redaction B [(B) = uncertain]
C Redaction C [(C) = uncertain]
χr Redaction at the level of "A", "B" or "C"
SpE Spätere Einschübungen (later interpolations — major redaction)
QLk Proto-Lukan recension of Q
8. Zeller (1977, 1982, 1984)
Q1 Early Sayings-Complexes
Q Other Q sayings & complexes
Q3 Late Hellenistic-Jewish redaction of Q