Biblical Criticism & History Forum - earlywritings.com

BeDuhn does not include the remainder in his minimal reconstruction, and the final part about his own country ('fatherland' might be a more literal translation) is, in my opinion, very unlikely to have been in the Evangelion because Jesus had just arrived on earth in 4.31, and he had not grown up i...

3) Finally, the argument presumes that the saying of Jesus in Luke 4.23, 'Physician, heal yourself; what we have heard you did at Capernaum, do here also in your own country' was present in the Evangelion, but only the 'physician heal yourself' part is positively attested to be there even assuming ...

This is a post I began a month or so ago. It is a quick and dirty look at the contents of Marcion versus the contents of Mark, Luke, and Matthew. It is not a full synopsis such as Peter Kirby is working on, not a list of material shared by the Evangelion and Mark or Matthew, but not in Luke. Both th...

For context, I posted on this argument on the Facebook Synoptic Problem Study Group back on February 23, 2024, and got feedback from Josen Rael and others. https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=10161682475903598&set=g.212992206399733 I have not yet reformulated the argument to take Jeff Cate's o...

For context, I posted on this argument on the Facebook Synoptic Problem Study Group back on February 23, 2024, and got feedback from Josen Rael and others. https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=10161682475903598&set=g.212992206399733 I have not yet reformulated the argument to take Jeff Cate's ob...

Peter Kirby wrote: ↑Mon Apr 08, 2024 6:08 am AFAIK it currently doesn't exist.

It is a goal of my synopsis and I can update you.

Thanks.

I would have to re-read the paper to be sure, but IIRC, Cook overplays his hand in eliding the difference between what Paul would have thought or expected to have happened and what he had an tradition that says this had happened. On the basis of the semantics of ἀνίστημι and ἐγείρω and the nature of...

Ben Smith's compilation of Luke-Evangelion overlaps together with the witnesses that attest to the Marcionite readings marks Marcionite readings that differ from the known text of Luke in blue boldface underline. Words or phrases attested as present in Marcion but either absent from or rendered diff...

Personally I intended to revisit the question after doing a synopsis based on my own particular approach. I am looking forward to seeing more of your synopsis and the Mark-Ev*-Luke theory (if that is still what you hold). I think your giving more credence to Epiphanius than Tertullian is probably a...

Giuseppe also wrote: are you asking me to wrote an entire book as K has done recently? I would take the hint and refer to Klinghardt's The Oldest Gospel and the Formation of the Canonical Gospels on this point . Ah. Ok. I'll take a look. Where does Klinghardt make the argument for the priority of t...