Biblical Criticism & History Forum - earlywritings.com

Ev was written by Luke and Matthew for me it is an unacceptable conclusion. Klinghardt or Harnack? I can concede willingly that *Ev is the top of the iceberg of multiple redactions, editings, dated back ultimately to an only scriptorium and hence to a lost proto-gospel. I don't concede that some of...

JarekS wrote: ↑Tue May 07, 2024 10:56 pm Ev was written by Luke and Matthew

for me it is an unacceptable conclusion.

But he didn't prove that *Ev was written by a single ghostwriter and that it wasn't Luke. You are claiming that *Ev was not written by a single ghostwriter and I can accept it, since some passages of the Passion story are more at home by a Judaizer ( = one who believes that the supreme god is YHWH)...

Only that in this case the privilege that was going to be conferred was not the privilege of being the Carrier of Jesus during the his entry in Jerusalem, but the privilege of being the first apostle of the gentiles and in extenso the destroyer of the Pagan world. We are referred to the way Barnabas...

In * Ev 8:26-39 the Gerasene Demonic is only one: 26 Then they arrived at the region of the Gerasenes,[a] which is opposite Galilee. 27 As he stepped out on shore, a man from the city who had demons met him. For a long time he had not worn any clothes, and he did not live in a house but in the tombs...

What is the point for which this is a case? And how does this make the case for that point? The point I am making thanks to Stuart's quote is that when a major precisation is made about god (in the specific case raised by Stuart in Mark 10:6 and 13:19: the attribute of creator ) then we are fully j...

Case in point (for which I am immensely grateful to Stuart): If there is anything in Mark that is possibly anti-Marcionite, and I think it's not specifically targeting Marcionites, as many gnostic teachings had the creator a lower entity than the father, then it would be verses 10:6 and 13:19. Mark ...

JarekS wrote: ↑Mon May 06, 2024 9:57 am DCHindleyI will be happy to read it, especially since I have just read Robert Wipper's Rome and Early Christianity.

Is there some possibility that this Wipper's book can be translated in English?

I invite to read Christ's Torah of Markus Vinzent.

I am angry with Martijn Linssen because he invited me to buy it in an ebook version, which I did.

At contrary it deserves to be read in the paper version.

Well, it could be food/daily sustenance, one of the necessities of life, as in 'Give us each day our daily bread.' Hardly so, since we are talking about the Evangelion of Marcion, and a similar case is proto-John, where the Paraclete, as a gift sent by the Father (probably not YHWH in proto -John) ...