Biblical Criticism & History Forum - earlywritings.com

JarekS wrote: ↑Mon May 06, 2024 9:57 am DCHindleyI will be happy to read it, especially since I have just read Robert Wipper's Rome and Early Christianity.

Is there some possibility that this Wipper's book can be translated in English?

I invite to read Christ's Torah of Markus Vinzent.

I am angry with Martijn Linssen because he invited me to buy it in an ebook version, which I did.

At contrary it deserves to be read in the paper version.

Well, it could be food/daily sustenance, one of the necessities of life, as in 'Give us each day our daily bread.' Hardly so, since we are talking about the Evangelion of Marcion, and a similar case is proto-John, where the Paraclete, as a gift sent by the Father (probably not YHWH in proto -John) ...

See here:

https://markusvinzent.blogspot.com/2011 ... l-220.html

Cool—-can you tell me how it is even possible to leave the Beatitudes on the cutting room floor? Ev priority over Mark solves a lot of problems, but I just can see anybody taking a razor blade to the Beatitudes. How is that even possible? The Beatitudes are pure marcionite theology: the woes, meant...

RandyHelzerman wrote: ↑Mon May 06, 2024 9:20 am

Giuseppe wrote: ↑Mon May 06, 2024 9:06 am you are talking to a *Ev prioritist,

A prioritist of Ev over Luke, or over Luke and Mark?

over Mark, Matthew and Luke (in that order).

Sometimes it happens to me fear for the life of Carrier when I remember that in America there is free circulation of firearms.

Another evidence of Markan antifeminism and anti-marcionism:

the episode of the Peter’s mother-in-law being healed by Jesus (so that she could "wait on them") was designed to legitimize married apostles (in contrast to Marcionite celibacy).

The woman who washed his feet certainly "got" fact that Jesus was going to die a horrible death, way before the male disciples did. you are talking to a *Ev prioritist, hence I remember that that woman was considered mentally a prostitute by Simon Peter in *Ev. Moving an embarrassed Mark ...

JarekS wrote: ↑Sun May 05, 2024 9:58 pm. It was created in the 19th century by William Benjamin Smith, Arthur Drews and Frederick Engels.

I have a great respect for W. B. Smith and Arthur Drews, and less for Engels and Bruno Bauer. Frankly the quality of the former can't be compared with the latter.